Location: 814 Saginaw Street
Phone: 989-892-4140
Hours: Mon. – Fri. 11:30 AM – 10 PM, Sat. (Lounge) 3 PM (Dining room) 4 PM – 10 PM
Reviewed on: Yelp and Urbanspoon

Old City Hall Website
We visited Old City Hall on a Thursday night with an interview candidate. Candidate J was a good sport and let me photograph dinner. This means if I had anything to say about it, Candidate J would get the job.
Old City Hall was pretty busy on both sides of the restaurant – the “lounge” side and the restaurant side – for a weeknight. The atmosphere is old Bay City, with exposed brick, wood, and low lights. It’s very nice. To start, we shared the Thai lettuce wraps and all of us ordered drinks. L, KB and Candidate J had wine, while AS had the smurf-colored Blue Lagoon martini. I am personally very skeptical of blue food items, but AS insisted it was “naturally blue” and quite good.

Thai Lettuce Wrap
The server, while a little nervous, was very good and made sure our food items came out in the right order and not too close together – the appetizer was enjoyed, a brief time passed, the salads and soup came out with bread, then after we were finished with those the entrees came out a little bit after. Everything was the right temperature, not cold or dried out from sitting under a heat lamp too long. This is a subtle point, but in a place like Old City Hall that advertises itself as “casual fine dining” and charges a bit more, it’s an important one. For me, more than the quality of the food (although that’s crucial), fine dining distinguishes itself in good service and attention to the details of the dining experience. This particular visit was very good in that aspect – other times have not been as good at OCH, and I’m hoping that this is the start of a trend.
On to the food. (Sorry about the dark pictures – still working on my photography skills in mood lighting.) AS ordered shrimp pad thai with the Blue Lagoon Martini, KB ordered Thai crusted salmon (there’s quite a Thai trend there!) with a salad, Candidate J had the twin medallions of beef with two sauces with a salad, and L had the New York strip with tomato bisque.

Tomato Bisque
AS said the Shrimp Pad Thai was very good, but she wished it was a bit more spicy and a little less salty. Candidate J liked the two medallions, and found the two sauces to be a nice contrast to each other, one a more heavy mushroom gravy and the other a fresher lemon herb sauce. KB, not usually one to order salmon, was pleased with the salmon and the vegetables that came along side. Both KB and Candidate J found the salads to be standard. The tomato bisque soup to start my meal was very good, one of the best versions of that soup I’ve ever had. My NY strip was also excellent, medium rare as I requested. I was also pleased with the vegetables – someone is paying more attention at OCH because the last couple times I have been there, the vegetables have been lacking – this time that was not the case. The blue cheese hash browns were also good, not your average potato side dish.
-
-
Thai Lettuce Wrap
-
-
Tomato Bisque
-
-
Ciabatta Bread
-
-
Side Salad
-
-
New York Strip
-
-
Shrimp Pad Thai
-
-
Beef Medallions w/ Two Sauces
-
-
Thai Crusted Salmon
Overall, we were very happy with the experience and KB and I both felt this was the best OCH experience we’d had. It’s a bummer to pay that much for dinner and be unhappy or unsatisfied, so we were pleased with this experience.
Summary: Old City Hall is a good place for business entertaining, a date or a special occasion dinner. The beer, wine and drink selection is extensive and the meals were really good this time. While the service has been spotty in the past, we had excellent service this time and we were happy with our dinner. It is living up to the “fine dining” in it’s “casual fine dining” catch phrase.